EU warns France about incompatibility of its biomethane certificate scheme
In Belgium, the European Commission decided to send a reasoned opinion to France (INFR(2026)4002) concerning the lack of compatibility of a national certificate scheme for biomethane production with the free movement of goods within the Internal Market (Articles 34-36 TFEU). Biomethane is a renewable gas made from organic waste that can be injected into natural gas networks. Under France’s scheme, suppliers must produce biomethane themselves or buy certificates from producers in mainland France.
Because the certificates are linked to production and import conditions, biomethane produced in other EU Member States is not recognized for traceability, even if certified as sustainable. This means that imported biomethane is excluded from the scheme, favoring local production. While supporting emissions-reduction goals, the Commission considers prioritizing domestic production disproportionate, as less restrictive options exist, such as counting biomethane where it is consumed rather than produced.
It also promotes EU-wide biomethane market integration through Member State cooperation, as outlined in the REPowerEU Action Plan. France is also in breach of the Single Market Transparency Directive (Directive (EU) 2015/1535) since the scheme and the respective national implementing measures were not notified to the Commission at a draft stage, prior to their adoption. Under the French scheme, suppliers must surrender certificates to the State in proportion to their sales to residential and tertiary consumers.
In addition, France published in October 2026 a decree prolonging the national certificate scheme until 2044 to take into account the decline in natural gas consumption and the (insufficient) development of the French biomethane market, further breaching the directive. The Commission sent a letter of formal notice to France in April 2026. The Commission considers that the explanations provided by France were unsatisfactory. Therefore, the Commission has decided to send a reasoned opinion to France, which now has two months to respond and take the necessary measures. Otherwise, the Commission may decide to refer the case to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
Category: Policy








