Browse > Home / Policy / Vinod Khosla says biofuels beat hybrids in key aspects of performance and carbon offset

Vinod Khosla says biofuels beat hybrids in key aspects of performance and carbon offset

March 19, 2008

Writing in Forbes, Vinod Khosla said that the best way to frame the renewables policy question was: “What is the cheapest way in dollars per ton to reduce carbon emissions from automobiles?”

He said that hybrids are a “PR gesture” because they can’t pay back their upfront investment in a reasonable amount of time, and added that McKinsey found that hybridization costs $90 per ton of carbon offset, the most expensive of all technologies. He added that battery technology is not moving fast enough to make electric cars feasible, except plug-in hybrids that will use coal-fired electricity that will increase emissions, not decrease them. Khosla said that GM’s Hummer V6 flex-fuel vehicle, running on Coskata cellulosic ethanol, would have half the emissions of a Prius running on gasoline.

Earlier this week, Khosla and Big Oil started a “food fight” at the Wall Street Journal’s ECO:nomics conference, where Khosla accused the American Petroleum Institute of hyping the link between food price increases to ethanol production, saying “The API started issuing press releases about food. Suddenly they got interested in the welfare of poor Africans.”

“We have never said anything about ethanol being responsible for food prices,” said American Petroleum Institute President Red Cavaney. “It was Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke in recent Congressional testimony who linked a 4.5% increase in food prices to rising worldwide demand and the amount of corn going to ethanol.”

Recently, “Vinod you are still totally clueless” and “there will be pie in the sky by-and-by” were among comments hurled at Khosla in response to a three-part series of articles posted at Grist.

The second series focused on Biomass, including regulatory standards , “better agronomy for energy crops” , and “cellulosic ethanol yields“.

Among dozens of responses, writers accused Khosla turning “self delusion” on carbon cycles into a “mass delusion”, adding comments such as “cellulosic ethanol is such BS and that’s not just for the fertilizer.”

Among other proposals, Khosla endorsed a CLAW standard for sustainable production of biomass:

C — COST below gasoline

L — low to no additional LAND use; benefits for using degraded land to restore biodiversity and organic material

A — AIR quality improvements, i.e. low carbon emissions

W — limited WATER use,

Last December, the Biofuels Digest Editorial Board voted Khosla a bronze Biofuels Digest Medal for Highest Achievement in Biofuels in 2007, along with George W. Bush, Elliott Mannis (CEO, D1 Oils), Bob Dineen (President, Renewable Fuels Association), Jeff Broin (CEO, Poet), Al Gore, Dr. Chris Somerville (scientist, University of California) and Ban Ki-moon (Secretary-General, United Nations). Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, the President of Brazil, received the silver, and Don Endres, CEO of VeraSun Energy, received the Gold medal.

  • San Francisco mayor orders development of Local Carbon Offset program; first in US
    • In California, the city of San Francisco has mandated the development of a Local Carbon Offset Program that will be the first in the United States. The program will establish a fund that will invest i...
  • Today in Biofuels: first commercial algae farm for biofuels in US; sizzling Khosla, Branson articles; 30 Hungarian ethanol projects dropped
    • Top Story: In Texas, PetroSun will open the first US commercial-scale algae farm for biofuels near South Padre Island. The 1,831 acre site includes 157 separate ponds, and the company said that ext...
  • Aussies reject ethanol, carbon offsets in national consumer survey
    • In Australia, a survey by insurance group AMMI found that more than half of Australian drivers will not use ethanol in their cars, due to concerns of engine damage. The survey also found that 13 perce...
  • Vinod Khosla slams environmentalists for lacking pragmatism
    • Vinod Khosla published three articles on Gristmill (Parts I, II, and III) under the title "Pragmatists vs. Environmentalists", in which the noted investor stated his objections to plug-in hybrids and ...
  • Federal Trade Commission to revise “green marketing” rules as Malaysian palm, Saab ads banned for greenwashing
    • The U.S. Federal Trade Commission has commenced hearings to revise standards for green marketing. The Commission's environmental marketing guidelines have not been updated since 1998, and do not inclu...
  • AgRefresh verifies 83,363 tonnes of dairy carbon offset credits in waste-to-energy programs
    • AgRefresh announced that they had verified 83,363 tonnes of carbon offsets, produced by dairy farmers undertaking waste-to-energy projects. The projects in the AgRefersh programs captured methane and ...

    Written by Jim Lane · Filed Under Policy 

    Comments

    Got something to say?

    You must be logged in to post a comment.