US and EU block Brazilian proposal to eliminate ethanol tariffs through World Trade Organization action

November 6, 2007

The United States and European Union have blocked a Brazilian proposal to include biofuels among “environmental goods” scheduled for tariff reduction or elimination in the next world trade treaty. The US and European position is that the environmental designation rules are for industrial products, not agriculture.

Brazil is expected to ask the World Trade Organization to investigate U.S. ethanol subsidies. If the WTO takes on the case, it will be the first time the organization has ruled on energy subsidies.

The convergence of energy and agriculture in the biofuels industry is expected to pose thorny questions for the WTO if it takes on the case. While neither sector has enjoyed free trade conditions, the subsidy mechanism which has supported national agriculture interests has attracted negative attention far more than the cartel approach employed in the oil industry.

The new Transatlantic Economic Council (TEC), which meets in Washington in November, is expected to propose definitive standards for biofuels trade. Recently, numerous European biodiesel producers have reduced capacity or shut down due to competition from subsidized soybean-based biodiesel from the United States. The European Biodiesel Board points out that biodiesel producers in the US receive a subsidy of up to $300 per ton, and that as a result, US producers can export to Europe for less than the cost that Europeans pay for raw materials.

Doha Round of trade talks: background

At a World Trade Organization meeting aimed at reviewing new proposals for the Doha Round of trade talks, New Zealand's WTO ambassador Crawford Falconer reported that a number of countries had express...

Brazil complaint to World Trade Organization over US ethanol tariff more likely

In Brazil, Cosan called on the Brazilian government to intervene with the US government more forcefully on ethanol tariff, and observers said that Brazil may take the US to the World Trade Organizatio...

UN Development Program calls on US, Europe to drop barriers to Brazilian ethanol

The United Nations Development Program called today for the elimination of the Brazilian ethanol tariff imposed by the US and Europe. The UNDP report said that Brazilian ethanol reduces greenhouse gas...

World Trade Organization launches inquiry into US farm subsidies; Canada, Brazil protests have effect

The WTO has commenced an investigation into US farm subsidies following protests from Canada and Brazil. The Canadians and Brazilians allege that the US has exceeded its $19.1 billion cap on farm sub...

Brazil on verge of WTO complaint against US over ethanol tariffs

Brazil is readying its challenge of US ethanol tariffs at the Wolrd Trade Organization. The 54-cent tariff is said by the Brazilians to be an illegal tariff under WTO rules. Unica has been working wit...

Brazil blasts US and Europe for “biased and protective agenda” on biofuels

Brazil accused the United States and Europe of having a "biased and protectionist agenda" at the World Trade Organization. Brazil was criticizing a proposed compromise on commercial rules which it sai...

Written by Jim Lane · Filed Under International, Policy, The Daily Biofuel Summary